New York City FC vs FC Cincinnati

New York City FC and FC Cincinnati have met 18 times — New York City FC won 9, FC Cincinnati won 6, with 3 draws. Their rivalry dates back to 2019. New York City FC leads the head-to-head with 9 victories from 18 meetings. A combined 65 goals have been scored across these fixtures, averaging 3.61 per match (37 for the home side, 28 for the visitors). Both teams scored in 10 matches (56%). Over 2.5 goals landed in 12 games (67%), making it a fixture that tends to produce goals. New York City FC are currently unbeaten in the last 4 meetings. The highest-scoring encounter finished 4–4 in 2026.